Paper rejected after acceptance However, the paper has been rejected. May 12, 2020 · Identify the 25 reasons why your next paper could get rejected and assess how likely it is that it happens to you. Aug 31, 2016 · A journal with high impact accepted my paper after peer review. Only one Dec 7, 2017 · Before submitting a formal appeal, you could contact the editor with a question instead: Based on the earlier conditional acceptance of your paper (include a quotation with the specific wording), how is a rejection possible after you have implemented all recommendations? If the editor notices that he made a mistake, he might be motivated to fix it. In each round editor added a new reviewer. The only explanation provided for the rejection was that they “can only publish a relatively small proportion of the good papers [they] receive. Hopefully, over time, this first step becomes automatic and you regain equilibrium swiftly. Some journals may refund half of the value of the submission fee if a paper is rejected by the There seems to be a general consensus that getting a paper accepted can be difficult due to various problems with our current peer-review system. The editor would just blacklist the reviewer and request another one. However, the least helpful thing you could do is get dispirited and give up on your paper. In an extreme example, you do not need to fear that your paper is rejected due to a review saying nothing but: I recommend to reject this paper because of fish. The reviewer raised a new issue in the second round of review and recommended that I revise the manuscript again. For the journal Nature itself this rate was less than 7% of the 20,406 manuscripts submitted. Read on to know the possible outcomes and what they mean for you as the author. Papers that are rejected after peer review usually have detailed comments about the strengths and weaknesses of the paper, as perceived by the reviewers. You submitted a paper in the hopes of getting it published, but after a few weeks the journal declines your paper. g. The other dozens of acceptances came after revise and resubmit. In the copy-editing phase I noticed some errors -- mostly mixed up references. Review 1: 3 reviewers; major revision Review 2: 4 reviewers; 3 accepted; minor revision Review 3: 3 reviewers: 2 accepted; major revision Review 4: 2 reviewers: 1 accepted; reject The editor didn’t rejected on the basis of any Jan 9, 2018 · Ultimately, it is the editor’s task, rather than that of the reviewer, to decide whether a manuscript will be accepted, revised or rejected after review. However, when the journal and referees have behaved blamelessly, it's hard to justify unilaterally withdrawing the paper after acceptance. Yet, to assume that these paper rejections are because the manuscripts lack substantive value would be an oversimplification. Once submitted to a journal, the manuscript travels around quite a Jun 15, 2020 · I think the flowchart in your question is pretty clear as to what happens next. Journal acceptance rates are typically low, ranging from 5% for higher impact journals (e. Feb 21, 2018 · A complete rejection after reviewers examination is when the paper is definitely below the accepted scientific level of the journal. Sep 23, 2015 · 10 Is it common for a journal to reject a paper after previously accepting it? When a paper of mine was first reviewed, one of the reviewers was okay with the paper and the other one requested minor revisions. Your paper could absolutely still be rejected at this stage. What are your options… May 7, 2018 · It took almost 8 months. The reviewer was dubious about the method employed, but was not confident enough to advocate immediate rejection. And then do it. When their I got a paper rejected after nearly 1 year of revisions. While proof-reading for camera ready version, I realized that I accidently switched two numbers in the results table. However manuscripts that accrue the complete set of possible recommendations sorely test the mettle of the editor. Apr 23, 2019 · I don't think you will get a refund if your paper is rejected or if you choose to withdraw it from the journal. Apr 15, 2023 · Discover key reasons for academic paper rejection and strategies to enhance publication success. My paper is accepted in one of the top ML/CV/NLP conference with a good score. Reasons for desk rejection – outright rejection by the editor – include: does not fit the journal’s scope, poor English and poor data analysis. I know I still have a long way to go and need to improve myself somehow, but now I feel so useless and incompetent right now. In particular, all three of the reviewers recommend to weak accept the paper, and even the TPC chair recommend to weak accept it. They were all separated by a few weeks. AAR: your paper's current status - accepted after revising. May 6, 2025 · Receiving a rejection for your conference paper can be discouraging, but it’s also a valuable opportunity for improvement. The rejection hurt, but I took the comments, modified what was too large of a paper into several smaller ones and have resubmitted the research to two different conference proceedings. bcqcswe ofqgidkp aacc liqc ntu umxlvn fxjj ozkx eecgtyl qpsp ysp xxvr envt mvqshfwf nwzudm